10:10:09 <ErCiccione> This is a fair request: https://github.com/monero-project/monero-site/pull/2143. Two years ago we denied it because they were unknown and now they are asking again to be listed. Thing is, personally i have no idea who these guys are, but if there are no claims of scamming, they are open source (they mention only the frontend being open source) and they are non custodial, i would be ok with listing them.
10:11:24 <ErCiccione> this itches me a little, because for this section we say "The wallets listed below are mobile or light wallets that are deemed safe by respected members of the community."
10:12:07 <ErCiccione> so i would be inclined to also change that phrasing and maybe add also here the "do your own research" disclaimer thing
10:20:40 <ErCiccione> (i'm talking about https://deploy-preview-2143--barolo-time-757cf9.netlify.app/downloads/#mobilelight)
13:08:46 <ofrnxmr[m]> never heard of, never used. would absolutely never recommend some random wallet with 0 users
13:11:14 <ofrnxmr[m]> stack and cake wallet arent given free passes.
13:11:14 <ofrnxmr[m]> person`lly, i dont like the idea of recommnding ANY centralized "not really monero" honeypot wallets
13:13:11 <ofrnxmr[m]> even mymonero is still not working properly with lws, and mymonero shoukd really be a last resort for people with poor connectivity and no need fir privacy
13:14:11 <ofrnxmr[m]> and yes im assuming that this is not a "full" wallet, but another view key honeypot
13:35:41 <MajesticBank> about coinspace wallet ? <ofrnxmr[m]> 
13:43:57 <plowsof11> alot of services use mymonero backend 
13:45:45 <plowsof11> coin wallet uses mymonero backend* 
13:46:47 <MajesticBank> https://github.com/CoinSpace/monero-core-js
13:47:07 <MajesticBank> https://github.com/CoinSpace/cs-monero-wallet/blob/master/index.js
13:48:15 <MajesticBank> There are several *high fee* scam reports in google store reviews
13:48:44 <MajesticBank> While I think we have only 2 mobile wallets on the site with full non-custodial local sync and we should leave many more
13:48:55 <MajesticBank> I don't think this wallet is a fit
13:49:46 <MajesticBank> *have many more, for best decentralization and more options
13:53:17 <MajesticBank> https://imgur.com/a/EpYMVOr
14:03:31 <ofrnxmr[m]> plowsof @plowsof:matrix.org:  im still down, otherwise id check it out myself. MajesticBank: thanks for checking reviews
14:18:56 <MajesticBank> maybe invite them to next community meeting (?), so community can ask questions, since they applied 2 years ago also just to make sure everyone agrees, but initial look doesn't seem solid
14:20:34 <ofrnxmr[m]> this weeks meeting might not happen (holiday or something?). but yeah, even if not the meeting they can come to #monero-community-dev:monero.social  to show it 
14:22:02 <ofrnxmr[m]> either way, unless its a "good" wallet, it need not be recommended on getmonero. YMMV wallets should be listed on coingecko or reddit 
14:25:20 <ofrnxmr[m]> if anyone shows up with a feather, cake. gui, stack, monerujo issue, i can be confident that the issues were not malicious, that they can and will be solved, and that its not some funky business going on on some backend server
14:28:31 <plowsof11> i will do another meeting next saturday (as 8th was already announced) 
14:28:45 <plowsof11> double* 
14:42:47 <ofrnxmr[m]> sounds good