05:08:09 Lol rotten reacted to his own post 🥴 06:50:08 how do i make a community of in person monero traders 06:50:12 monero for cash 06:50:21 without getting my door kicked down by law enforcement immediately 06:53:01 I don't think monero has so bad reputation, what country do you live in? 06:55:08 a country thats run by jews 07:08:09 Better run by jews then jhiadist 07:25:33 how do you guys rate matrix/element privacy from 0 to 10? 07:36:56 8 maybe? It’s pretty good w decentralization but your profile can still be correlated across multiple rooms and logged like irc since they’re tied to the same profile/identity. 07:36:57 Simplex Chat is awesome in this regard, the rooms are entirely p2p (doesn’t even require home servers, don’t get more decentralized than that lmao) you can anonymously join rooms and it gives you a new anonymous profile name by default and there’s no identifiable link to you whatsoever unless you fail w opsec and drop hints haha. It’s got other cool features too like tor o 07:36:59 nly message relay servers by default, two separate servers for inbound and outbound messages, stores all chats locally and more. 07:37:01 Found it pretty neat and definitely worth checking out. 07:37:58 8 maybe? It’s pretty good w decentralization but your profile can still be correlated across multiple rooms and logged like irc since the chats are tied to the same profile/identity. 07:37:59 Simplex Chat is awesome in this regard, the rooms are entirely p2p (doesn’t even require home servers, don’t get more decentralized than that lmao) you can anonymously join rooms and it gives you a new anonymous profile name by default and there’s no identifiable link to you whatsoever unless you fail w opsec and drop hints haha. It’s got other cool features too like tor o 07:38:01 nly message relay servers by default, two separate servers for inbound and outbound messages, stores all chats locally and more. 07:38:03 Found it pretty neat and definitely worth checking out. 07:42:17 My issue with Simplex is that for now it is effectively centralized, although they're apparently planning on adding other providers onto the default list in addition to people already being able to add their own. Also really afraid of enshittification because of venture capital, really hope it doesn't though. 07:42:28 Also easy to host a server for. 07:45:24 yes it seems good, creating invite links works almost like creating new subaddresses for monero account, the concept is interesting for sure 07:49:49 A feature I really like is that the link for adding a contact guarantees you'd use the right public key. It is like checking the key fingerprints immediately after adding a contact but just ensures it's done. 09:13:28 Hey guys. 09:13:29 I would like to throw an idea here. 09:13:31 Recently I thought that an alternative to chatgpt with a more privacy focus and possibility to pay with monero would be interesting. 09:13:33 Basically hosting our own LLM probably llama or similar, making sure that chat are private and accepting monero as payment. 09:13:35 Would anyone be interested into something like that? 09:13:37 This is just an idea at the moment. 09:13:39 Let me know if this is not directly enough related to monero and I'll post in offtopic instead. 09:15:10 I thought AI hype train derailed already. 09:15:48 Not trying to do anything hyped. Just providing alternative for privacy conscious people. 09:16:13 But happy to be told if it is useless. 09:18:28 People apparently see use it it, so my feedback can probably be ignored. I don't get AI and see it as a hype train. 09:19:12 "This is how, with a few simple tricks, a loaf of white (or black) bread can be turned into a trolleybus... But what for?" 09:20:29 I think it has its uses. Mostly as an alternative search engines to me. Good for docs. But definitely overhyped for sure. 09:23:26 I like its use for summaries of things that are overly long, but only those that are like this for no reason, not the long essays that just have a lot of details to say. 09:23:36 As for search engines - would rather not. 09:37:07 inspired by that reddit post of similar service? 09:37:32 I missed that. Can you point it out? 09:37:55 https://old.reddit.com/r/Monero/comments/1ggzspl/monero_now_live_on_nanogpt_use_all_the_big_llms/ 09:39:52 Oh wow. Alright. Then forget it hahaha. I was too late ;) 09:40:41 However it seems they just use token so your chat still go to chatgpt I was thinking more of self hosted LLM. 09:41:27 Nvm they have the self hosted one as well. 09:47:46 I mean they are running analytics on the website... 09:48:21 oh nvm 13:26:33 Im a Monero only guy. Where is the XMR payment option? All I see is Nano. real disappointing 13:28:16 I say use SimpleX Chat. Matrix is 1 - 2 out of 10 13:30:35 Homeservers can identify you from metadata. Most public homeservers are hosted using cheap instances from Hetzner. Germany was great during WWII but now they’re cucked ha ha 13:32:06 I am a Monero-only person online, even if not entirely by choice. 13:32:42 Homeservers' problem is how omnipresent matrix.org is, it has an eye seemingly everywhere :/ 13:34:00 Germany hosts the most number of monero nodes btw 13:34:06 true 13:34:50 what about xmpp/jabber? it's old and has many users, not everyone has SimpleX 13:35:13 knownsec, same for Tor nodes. It, Netherlands and the US seem to be the biggest. 13:35:49 One of the reasons why I host my own node! 13:35:58 I like XMPP because it's easy to host, very unlikely to enshittify and the metadata problems are pretty easily addressable. 13:38:13 plowsof xmrscott this is the second this user is openly showing support for nazism. I'm pretty sure this is against libera chat rules. Please proceed to ***CENSOR*** him. 13:38:55 Did I join the community at a bad time? 13:39:18 mhm. as a first impression I would say they were better time. It's not particularly a bad time tho 13:39:30 in general i mean 13:39:41 SyntethicBird is a weirdo. Don't worry about the schizo 13:39:47 No 13:40:05 a week ago it wss invite-only 13:40:07 Schizo here is you - being either an edgelord or something much worse. 13:40:22 Germany hosts the most number of monero nodes btw <<>> because people use hetzner for vps 13:40:23 Nazi / political shit is offtopic here 13:40:30 plowsof xmrscott ^ I think that's enough of an hint he is a troller 13:40:51 I'm not censored this much on X so why would I be here? 13:40:52 I dont think he's trolling 13:41:00 And he's far from the only nazi here 13:41:03 Because Musk is a cartoon villain. 13:41:18 Markus: there are more channels you can explore, this one is often offtopic and flooded. 13:41:19 our rooms are focused on topics. This in #monero 13:41:33 Dont bring your political jibber jabber here 13:41:41 I am a monero maxi 13:41:44 This is a decentralization revolution with privacy at the forefront 13:41:45 There are more? 13:41:47 when I joined earlier today there was a guy that didn't seem to like jews 🤣 13:41:49 so, maybe it's a common thing here 13:41:52 And im a jew 13:42:27 That sounds dreadful 13:42:28 You're not a banker so I don't care 13:42:33 don't care its ethically wrong, libera prohibited and illegal under swedish law (on which libera chat operate) 13:42:38 If u wanna fight, u can find me in dm 13:42:47 Not that you are a jew, but the comment about it 13:42:55 If its not about monero, dont post it here 13:43:27 Everything was going fine until SyntheticBird the schizo derailed this chat 13:43:38 #monero-community:monero.social #monero-community-dev:monero.social #monero-dev:monero.social #monero-offtopic:monero.social #monero-research-lab:monero.social #monero-research-lounge:monero.social 13:44:09 Idc about peoples political affiliations. Not my problem. Going offtopic with them is. Dont pollute "monero" with "my country is better than yours" 13:44:24 Monero doesnt give a fk about your country or band of incels 13:45:38 No man should be cut off of the system for what he says or supports. Banning me is ironic like the centralized exchanges that are banning Monero 13:45:49 You cant stop a jew from using monero, and you cant stop a nazi from using monero. Go cry a river about your beliefs elsewhere. This room is about monero, not about history 13:46:03 So stfu about non-monero related topics 13:46:20 All I talk about is Monero 13:46:36 you get kicked from -dev for talking about the weather, you get kicked from -community for talking about the weather 13:46:37 THERE IS NO STOPPING THE MONEROLUTION 13:46:39 fallacious arguments after fallacious arguments. you must really have nothing else to do in your life 13:47:32 Feel free to keep talking about monero - without adding in your politics 13:47:48 I'm sure theres a monero-politics rooms somewhere on discord or telegram 13:48:03 Half are invite only 13:48:11 hold i'll invite you 13:48:25 I’ve had men in suits visit me for speaking about Monero not my politics 13:48:43 Monero is more threatening 13:48:44 Good for you 13:48:57 Did they bring strapons? 13:49:12 Markus: you should have received 4 invites 13:49:15 Spreading the word of Monero and educating people is what I do 13:49:19 I would be interested by some groups also if possible dear bird :p 13:49:35 Nobody cares about threats. Real slowly: this room is for monero, not politics 13:49:51 Mollylucy, the same rooms are avail on irc 13:49:54 MollyLucy by groups you mean channels ? 13:50:08 #moneo-offtopic for example 13:50:14 yeah like ofrnxmr said irc user don't need invites 13:50:19 #monero-offtopic 13:50:20 the private telegram/discord channels yes :) 13:50:36 #monero-offtopic 13:50:37 #monero-research-lab 13:50:37 I'm also gonna join the irc groups, thanks! 13:50:39 #monero-lounge 13:50:41 #monero-dev 13:50:43 #monero-community-dev 13:50:59 <3 13:51:03 you can't rate services this way, all of them have their own threat model, you have to define your threat model then pick an instant messaging app that suites you. 13:51:03 https://www.privacyguides.org/en/basics/threat-modeling/ 13:51:05 https://www.privacyguides.org/en/real-time-communication/ 13:51:12 MollyLucy: enjoy 13:51:56 fwiw I like to also rate the real ability and seriousness of a service at providing its threat model guarantees. 13:51:57 Using the internet in any way is risky and if your threat model is high enough no service you use will help 13:52:54 I only use mullvad /s meme 13:53:34 I only use mullvad but unironically 13:54:04 Mavrick, how do you use xmr? 13:54:23 Cake Wallet 13:54:33 Exodus on PC 13:55:44 \> Complain about internet insecure and importance of threat model 13:55:45 \> Use a proprietary wallet 13:56:29 macOS 13:56:31 too 13:56:46 mamma mia 13:57:05 I'm fully doxxed schizo 13:57:32 Like I said, I’ve had men in suits visit me already 13:58:49 Were they playboy bunny suits? 14:00:46 What are you yapping about? 14:01:35 You said you had men in suits visit. I asked if they were playboy bunny suits. 14:01:48 You're trolling 14:02:22 ? Not really 14:03:25 Are you going to Monerotopia next year? 14:03:34 I can't make it this year 14:03:35 Would be a more interesting story if yku said "yes" 14:03:42 This year? 14:03:57 You're an interesting person 14:04:01 Oh. Next year. Idk. I dont plan further ahead than the next day or so 14:04:13 Thank you 14:04:45 You should relate considering the attacks launched on you 14:06:07 The attacks against me here were and will always be pathetic and not worth losing sleep over 14:06:42 I've had much worse drama irl, even during the same time. Bot spamming is kind of hilarious tbh 14:07:02 We will never see something like this again as people will focus on privacy and there will be too many targets 14:07:51 Nothing is going to beat monero, I’m all in and can’t imagine a world where people don’t value privacy 14:08:20 Most people don’t know a “Monero” even exists 14:08:28 I dont think ppl will use monero because its private, but because it works and is safe 14:09:00 Privacy is a nice buzzword, but most ppl dont care about it. People _do_ care about their bottom line 14:09:06 Bitcoin is a public bank account 14:09:24 Parents like to tell kids "im broke" when asking for allowance. You cant do that when you use btc 14:09:47 Bitcoin isnt used as a currency therefore it wont have as much demand as say Monero will. Its swept the dark web and the community is constantly innovating 14:09:57 Businesses like to keep orders and sales / partnerships private from competitors. cant do that with btc 14:10:27 No one uses Bitcoin. The funniest part is people speculate on it being a currency 14:10:36 Maybe do your Monero shilling outside of the Monero rooms so it's not a circlejerk since you love to advocate for it so much? 14:10:47 Monero won't win because its "a privacy coin", it will win because it is safe 14:10:48 I do on X 14:10:57 @moneromavrick on X 14:11:04 I'm thinking Wownero has a good chance in blowing up, afterall, it looks like Monero is getting delisted and banned in certain places. 14:11:17 ... cant a guy get a little jerk sometimes? Its lonely out here 14:11:45 How long until governments realize you cannot ban an idea 14:11:48 Drug dealers will launder using Wownero so yes 14:12:10 BTC has considerable fees so not really usable in transfers like I have - around $5. 14:12:15 I think they already realized, thats why there is so much attempt at smoking the implementations before it blow up. 14:12:23 Btc fees are the same as monero tbf 14:12:25 It's that what bitcoin was first used for, crime. 14:12:40 Isn't that what bitcoin was first used for, crime. 14:12:54 0.00004xmr 0.00004btc 18.4m 19.5m 14:13:01 ofrnxmr, I thought they weren't cents or fractions thereof. 14:13:32 Privacy coins are just now what bitcoin was 7 years ago. 14:13:33 BlueyHealer, fees are the same on atomic units but the value of bitcoin made it so these fees are way higher 14:14:05 Theyre only cents because xmr is valued at 155usd. If xmr was valued at 70k fees woukd be $2.8 14:14:17 Yeah, but right now it isn't. 14:14:31 Perhaps not even 2.8 because of the dynamic block size 14:14:40 Government bans have worked. Only the future will tell if we were successful in creating a large Monero circular economy. This is our hope 14:14:49 yes 14:14:51 It will be once the supply is distributed and used to require value transfer / storage above 3b 14:15:04 Doesnt work as great as it sounds 14:15:21 Stressnet barely moved the fee, if at all, with 7mb blocks 14:15:27 Monerica, XMRBAZAAR, Monero Market. We need more 14:15:37 articmine must be stressing 14:15:51 But then how do you ban it? You just rename, fork it? Maybe under a different name its legal again 14:16:41 fork it, lose its value, governance chaos, trust issues, troller flooding, code maintenance challenge => it will die 14:16:43 The block penalty seemed tk be strange as well. Never penalized the whole reward (or even like 10% of it) 14:17:00 Governments are powerful and if they wanted to ban Monero completely they can 14:17:12 Monero is still small 14:17:21 Monero is only 3b market cap 14:17:23 I dont think so 14:17:28 Its just cold 14:17:43 Yea 14:17:48 Legislation with catch-all phrases "Privacy enhancing cryptocurrencies, ring signatures, opaque blockchain" etc etc 14:18:07 Governments cant ban a space internet 14:18:09 It doesn't matter if you fork it, it will fall under those categories 14:18:11 Screwing monero on the isp lvl is far from impossible 14:18:16 (starlink) from our saviour 14:20:49 Dubai use deep packet inspection, or at least they did on certain protocol usage, the great firewall. 14:21:22 Any VOIP protocols were inspected and filtered for years 14:21:43 Country wide, they also did ban monero already too 14:22:26 Governments have not completely banned Monero for now. Why? They use it themselves 14:22:41 Monero is helpful for the CIA and other agencies 14:23:04 How tf can you ban Monero 14:23:20 I'm thinking Wownero has a good chance in blowing up, afterall, it looks like Monero is getting delisted and banned in certain places. <<>> b4 being delisted wow needs to first be listed lol 14:23:20 Maybe with selective enforcement lol 14:23:48 It's probably useful for corrupt Government officials to launder war crime funds from Blackrock 14:25:32 That's the kind of behavior that starts revolutions though, non specific law. 14:29:49 mavrick glows so hard lmao 14:32:07 Don't we all tho 14:49:24 you can with everthing, Tor etc call it a terrorists tool, 14:54:28 Tor project calls monero a terrorist tool? Sauce 14:54:30 indeed 14:54:47 Sounds like the pot calling the grass black 14:55:46 no, I meant labeling such "tools" as terrorists eanbling tools 14:55:50 no, I meant labeling such "tools" as terrorists enabling tools 14:55:57 or whatever they call it nowadays 15:04:53 Sauce 15:14:16 https://www.wired.com/story/neo-nazis-flee-telegram-encrypted-app-simplex/ 15:14:17 https://gnet-research.org/2024/10/04/the-rise-of-monero-iskps-preferred-cryptocurrency-for-terror-financing/ 15:14:19 And Tor uou know 15:14:28 https://www.wired.com/story/neo-nazis-flee-telegram-encrypted-app-simplex/ 15:14:29 https://gnet-research.org/2024/10/04/the-rise-of-monero-iskps-preferred-cryptocurrency-for-terror-financing/ 15:14:31 And Tor you know 15:21:17 who will tell them how many Nazis there are on Facebook or Youtube) 15:21:34 Oh, you mean "they" call tor, monero, cash, pen and paper, in person conversations, handshakes, hugs etc terrorism 15:21:42 I thought "they" was tor 15:23:57 Also wasn't, erm, certain 2021 event organized IN THE CLEARNET? 15:24:06 (offtopic): fwiw simpleX owner is in good stance with that matter of fact. 15:24:49 That's why I keep warning about allowing/mentioning any thing that might be slightly illegal. There's a reason why Tor project are not facing *real* issues, they are simply avoiding it. 15:25:23 dont mention gambling folks, rando might get triggered 15:25:57 Everything is illegal yknow 15:26:34 We have a casino in our mall, lol. 15:26:48 Dont tell rando that. 15:26:49 They just call it "sports betting" for some reason. 15:26:55 yeah, I'm joking btw. 15:27:07 yeah, I'm not joking btw. 15:27:31 Tor faces no real issues because its centralized and regular users dont run relays or exits 15:27:58 It was created by the government 15:28:37 I wouldn't worry anyway because it's not my government anyway) 15:29:20 (but on a serious note, the deanon attacks don't seem passive from the description, so about established wanted people rather than casual browsing) 16:14:17 If monero only allows a few transactions at a time (aka pending balance), how could someone even setup a platform in which users can withdraw their coins efficiently 16:14:42 Having multiple inputs 16:15:02 isn’t that limited as well? 16:15:15 only unconfirmed funds are locked 16:15:28 Each deposit is an input, so lets say 100 people sent xmr to the service, that would be 100 outputs that the service owned 16:15:59 oh, i feel stupid now 16:16:01 The service would be able to send multiple withdrawals depending on the output skde 16:16:13 thank you lol 16:16:13 Size 16:16:59 I thought you mean sending to multiple recipients 16:17:29 If someone deposited 1000xmr in one tx and 100ppl try to withdraw 10xmr each ; how many hours will it take ? 16:17:45 https://repo.getmonero.org/monero-project/ccs-proposals/-/merge_requests/469#note_26940 16:17:45 did you know that there a so much spy nodes and it is so easy to make? just proxy of the same nodes... 16:17:47 and this is done through subaddresses right? in the monero RPC, i would utilize sub addresses? and each transaction to that would be its own input? or is there a specific means of generating an address in rpc for this? because to my understanding before there were limited inputs 16:18:10 If you split the tx first , not that long 16:18:20 yeah that sounds like an issue to me as well, because the 1000 xmr would become pending until the first transaction cleared 16:18:22 How much time though? 16:18:39 sweeping outputs? 16:18:59 No, any new incoming transaction remains a separate output until combined in a spend that consumes the whole output 16:19:33 alright 16:19:39 16 outputs * 10xmr = 160 xmr, 1000 / 160 = ~6 tx 16:20:06 7 * 20min = 2hr20min 16:20:46 Actually maybe less 16:21:11 Easier would be 1000/16 > then 7 txs ; so 40min approx 16:21:18 Can split it into 16, then spend directly from that, splitting each 16 again in the aftual spends 16:21:55 Chainanalysis would be having a field day 16:22:18 Make sure to use their node 16:23:16 what’s this 16 number related to? now i am confused because you said each monero transaction is its own input or output wtv, but if the network limits ur wallet to 16 at a time, how does this work? (excuse me if im being slow) 16:23:42 16 max outputs per tx 16:24:10 In this case, outputs = recipients 16:24:11 for 1 wallet address? 16:24:37 so the limit for how many outputs u can combine to place into one transaction? 16:24:52 Any address 16:24:53 No, the limit for that is ~148 16:24:55 OH 16:24:58 Wait no i understand 16:25:10 you’re referring to pay to many 16:25:12 148 outputs ? 16:25:13 148 max in, 16 max out 16:25:27 Inputs 16:26:01 (100kb) max for inputs is ~148 inputs 16:26:11 This feels like a very complicated thing to integrate into a website 😃 16:27:41 actually I think such services use separate subaddresses (maybe combined with integrated addresses) and they don't store funds in only one address 16:27:43 and btw the whole balance won't become locked anyways, so you don't have to wait even if all funds are in one address 16:27:45 correct me if I'm wrong 16:28:38 I think it's actually easy, just have a look at monero rpc docs, it's actually simple and I tried using it, it's fast even with remote node 16:28:56 If someone deposited 1000 xmr at once, it will be 1 input 16:29:16 yes and it will be locked until confirmed 16:29:23 Balances arent locked per address, but pet input 16:29:35 agreed 16:29:38 yeah, integrating the monero rpc is simple like any other thing, the balance locking seems to complicate things for me though 16:30:08 balance locking is better describes as "locking of input/output used" 16:30:37 Your whole balance doesnt get locked, the inputs you spend and receive does 16:32:17 I was thinking about it too, then asked chatgpt and it clarified for me so I understood it easily 16:32:17 so how do you effectively work around this? say my website had someone deposit 1000xmr and i had 50 addresses i needed to withdraw to, what would i even do because this wouldn’t be possible 16:32:47 Actually what I still don't understand is why you remain private initiating the transaction 16:33:12 what did you do? some sort of queueing system? 16:33:17 Actually what I still don't understand is how you remain private initiating the transaction, especially when there are so much spy nodes 16:33:33 that’s sounding like my only option at the moment with from what i understand of the network 16:34:29 queuing transactions and i guess breaking all the inputs using sweeping? then sending out the next group of transactions etc.. 16:34:49 i think you can just connect through tor 16:35:09 i wouldn’t ever connect to a monero node without a tor proxy unless i owned the node anyways 16:38:55 Youd withdraw to 16 at a time 16:40:03 You run you own node or use a node via onion or i2p 16:40:24 And if you run your own node, you configure it to relay tx via tor or i2p 16:40:49 you don't have to implement queuing, just send xmr, it become unlocked when confirmed, that's simple 16:40:49 you building some payment system? 16:42:10 ur balance locks, like if i received 2 xmr and sent 1.5 using that input, my 0.5xmr would be locked until that payment confirmed so i couldn’t process a withdraw of 0.5 until after that payment did confirm 16:42:17 really I can do that? can it be configured through GUI? 16:42:32 yes im building a payment system 16:42:58 Yea but probably easier to use a config file 16:43:00 oh srry, configure it for node, I understand 16:44:29 no, only your 1.5 xmr will be locked, 0.5 you can spend 16:45:36 so if you recieve 1.5 to your 0.5 balance address, while your 1.5 is locked until 10 confirmations, you can still spend your 0.5 balance 16:45:52 i think ur wrong, the transaction seems to take the 2 xmr from that input, send it to the address, and send the change back to ur wallet aka locking the 0.5 xmr 16:46:21 until that outgoing 1.5 is confirmed 16:46:48 sorry if i described it poorly 16:47:17 but yeah, this is my concern for the payment system im developing, seems a simple system like we would use with bitcoin isn’t possible, and im going to have to develop some queuing system 16:50:07 if you have outgoing 1.5 xmr - the locked amount will be 1.5 xmr, not 2 xmr or any other amount 16:50:56 just try sending some small amounts between your addresses and you'll understand how it works, I was concerned about this question too 16:51:37 i have, when i send funds, all of the funds from the input i used to form the transaction are locked until my outgoing funds are confirmed 16:51:55 this is why the wallet shows unconfirmed balance after i send funds to someone 16:52:45 yes, so it will not prevent you from spending remaining balance 16:53:36 I think building payment system is easy because most of the work is handled by monero network and it's concepts 16:53:57 i can spend unconfirmed balance still? 16:54:40 I think we talk about different things by "unconfirmed balance" 16:54:48 yeah, i mean connecting to rpc and all that is as easy as any other crypto but monero is a lot different to work with 16:54:50 sorry my english is not perfect actually 16:54:51 No 16:55:04 it’s alright, i understand 16:55:12 the 0.5 (change) will be locked 16:55:14 probably 16:58:31 should i just schedule a from job to send 16 transactions then wait for their confirmation then send the next 16 etc.. 16:58:40 should i just schedule a cron job to send 16 transactions then wait for their confirmation then send the next 16 etc.. 16:59:57 No 17:00:18 Just check check rpc for the output to be unlocked 17:01:06 isn’t the output becoming unlocked happen when the transaction is confirmed 17:01:55 just so you guys know im not normally this stupid, don’t judge 17:01:58 this is just new to me and confusing lol 17:05:04 image.png 17:09:36 actually there is a great feature in monero - integrated addresses, with that you can trace incoming transactions easily (give it specific payment id), it's first example on rpc docs page 17:09:37 I think bitcoin doesn't have this feature 17:09:57 Your "change" is a part of the transaction, and becomes unlocked at the same time as the transaction 17:11:54 why is part of transaction? 17:11:55 again, his balance is 2 XMR fully confirmed 17:11:57 he transfers 1.5 XMR - it becomes locked 17:11:59 he still has 0.5 XMR - it is not locked and can be spend even if 1.5 is not confirmed yet 17:12:01 isn't it right? 17:12:14 why is it part of transaction? 17:12:15 again, his balance is 2 XMR fully confirmed 17:12:17 he transfers 1.5 XMR - it becomes locked 17:12:19 he still has 0.5 XMR - it is not locked and can be spend even if 1.5 is not confirmed yet 17:12:21 isn't it right? 17:12:41 why is it part of transaction? 17:12:41 again, his balance is 2 XMR fully confirmed 17:12:43 he transfers 1.5 XMR - it becomes locked 17:12:45 he still has 0.5 XMR - it is not locked and can be spent even if 1.5 is not confirmed yet 17:12:47 isn't it right? 17:13:04 User A sends 2xmr to user B. User B sends 1.5xmr to user C. When User B sends this, it sends the 2xmr input and received change of 0.5xmt 17:13:39 Same as if you use a $20 bill to buy something worth $15 17:14:28 one reason the change is locked, is to prevent spending which could expose which output was change vs which output was the recipients 17:22:19 I think I understand, but you can specify higher change with rpc? monero gui won't let you increase change amount? 18:03:38 Change amount is equal to the difference between the input amount of the transaction and the actual amount you want to transact. 18:03:39 If you use a bigger input amount, the change amount will be bigger 18:34:40 image.png 18:34:41 does that mean there are 75% of spy nodes? 18:34:43 https://repo.getmonero.org/monero-project/ccs-proposals/-/merge_requests/469#note_26940 18:35:19 No, more like 10% 18:36:25 Wait.. let me reread 18:38:41 Yes. Looks like yes 19:33:37 <3​21bob321:monero.social> Exciting 19:33:43 <3​21bob321:monero.social> Spy games 19:34:25 Hi 19:34:45 Hi gf2718 19:35:53 Cool to use IRC channels and other clients :) 19:36:10 Question which I still don't have clear answer. 19:36:18 spy gaming 19:36:19 Do monero uses UTXO? 19:36:57 Monero uses input/output model but very different in regards to UTXO 19:37:10 By definition, one cannot verify publicly whether an output is unspent, so Monero doesn't have the UXTO concept 19:37:23 ^ gf2718 19:38:25 gf2718 if you'd like to read more, search 'RingCT' 19:38:34 dEBRUYNE: Ah yeah obviously ^^' 19:38:44 Ah yeeeah Ring signature! 19:38:56 Ring signature is different than RingCT 19:38:58 Pre-RingCT transactions are publicly-verifiable as their amounts are not masked 19:39:13 Those are I think 2017 and earlier, something like that 19:39:37 Similar names but very different concepts :) 19:40:08 m-relay: Yeah good point I see 19:42:27 dEBRUYNE: Ah yeah ok I see it's more based on some combinations of each input signature. 19:44:33 Outputs are essentially used as 'decoys', to create a ring for each input that is being spent 19:44:50 For an observer, it will not be clear which input is the real one and which one is the decoy 19:45:09 Current ring size is 16 19:45:17 FCMP++ will substantially improve Monero's privacy protocol, see -> https://www.getmonero.org/2024/04/27/fcmps.html 19:45:23 recanman: Yes, ty for adding! 19:45:29 Not just one decoy (impression I got from dEBRUYNE's wording) 19:45:55 gf2718 FCMP uses a newer cryptographic model that does not rely on ring signatures, see that link above 19:46:07 The Curve Trees paper is a good read as well. It is based on curve trees 19:46:21 The main issue with Ring Signatures is the need to keep a local index along with issues with the decoy selection algorithm 19:46:36 Some research was done, here https://github.com/Rucknium/OSPEAD 19:47:26 Statistical analysis due to decoy selection along with EAE has been the main issue 19:47:31 Statistical analysis due to decoy selection along with EAE have been the main issues 19:47:47 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iABIcsDJKyM 19:49:48 Oh, poisoned dust as well, the video I linked mentions that 19:50:21 Is this the on I think I read on a kewbit blog that can use any number of transactions in the blockchain as proofs? Just wondering if it's the same as FCMP++ 19:50:29 Yeah, pretty much 19:51:15 recanman: I see how it could be read like that yes 19:51:21 Is the ++ representative of the dandelion implementation with it 19:51:31 No 19:51:41 Spend Authorization + Linkability 19:51:43 Shortened to ++ 19:51:55 >"FCMPs+SA+L", later shortened to simply "FCMP++s", independently adds "Spend Authorization + Linkability", removing the dependency of Seraphis. 19:51:55 https://www.getmonero.org/2024/04/27/fcmps.html 19:52:08 Gotcha 19:53:44 Ah yeah I'm watching the Estimation plan of OSPEAD indeed I see the fundamental difference! 19:54:17 Yeah, that won't be implemented in Monero due to FCMP, but it shows (some) of the issues with ring signature model 19:54:34 https://github.com/Rucknium/misc-research/blob/main/Monero-Black-Marble-Flood/pdf/monero-black-marble-flood.pdf 19:54:49 Here's another issue: effective ring size decrease due to flooding 19:55:17 What am I looking at in this that adds value from whats written originally? https://kewbit.org/in-simple-terms-monero-fcmp-explained/ 19:55:22 This is all Rucknium's research, not mine* 19:55:23 >According to my estimates, mean effective ring size has decreased from 16 to 5.5 if the black marble flooding hypothesis is correct 19:55:47 I think it is just a summary Markus 22:05:17 ***Stop research on monero!*** 22:05:17 - Piconeros were never supposed to be quantified 22:05:19 - Years of churning PhD research yet no optimal action found! 22:05:21 - Wanted to go more private just for a laugh? We had a tool for that: It was called exchanging goods. 22:05:23 LOOK at what statisticians, cryptographer and developer have been asking your respect for: 22:05:25 ??? 22:05:27 ????? 22:05:29 ?????????? 22:05:31 "Hello I would ** XMR please" 22:05:33 ***They have played us for absolute fools*** 22:21:44 how much btc they paid u? 22:46:57 https://matrix.monero.social/_matrix/media/v1/download/monero.social/qpKoFUZvCImQTgzgMKPUMGEc 22:47:22 None. I just felt ***enlightened*** by this https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/stop-doing-math 22:49:55 I lost connection to Monero community workgroup help 22:50:04 Is it overloaded? 22:50:36 I can still view the channel 22:57:36 Nah just forever loads on laptop, phone it’s gone 23:17:21 Same 23:17:49 Happened a couple days ago for me. Happened in monero and dev too, maybe others 23:28:12 Can’t we afford to just make a home server 23:28:27 Or something with a bit more 💣 23:28:44 monero.social _is_ our homeserver 23:28:59 Crank it up? 23:29:12 From 3Ghz to 5Ghz 23:29:20 I thought it was effecting me bcuz i'm on monero.social, but i guess its an issue with the rooms 23:29:26 we could always ask to update synapse or switch to conduwuit 🏳️‍⚧️🦴 (yes the emojis are part of the name) 23:29:45 Synapse was updated 23:30:05 I dont think its synapse, i think the db is corrupted or smthn 23:30:17 My theory which is a completely uneducated one on this particular matter is that you need some extra dedotated wam to the server 23:30:27 Syn, you probably think plowsof is just a P (no profile pic) 23:30:33 But he does have a profile pic 23:30:39 i know 23:30:43 I can see it with other instances 23:30:52 Yeah 23:31:21 I’ve always seen this plowsoff as a P 23:31:21 this room (#monero) lost its pic and ita address. #haveno lost its address 23:31:23 is the *dedotated wam* with us in the room right now ? 23:31:42 Its like the db gets restored to earlier dates or somethinng 23:32:05 No it is honestly a simple solution 23:32:08 Just go here 23:32:12 https://downloadmoreram.com/ 23:32:27 Once downloaded install and you’re good 23:32:28 it might actually be the case 23:32:29 Kewbit, look at haveno's room address. It doesnt have one 23:32:41 who is the maintainer already ? 23:32:45 pigeons ? 23:32:56 I personally added haveno:monero.social and a few months later it was rm -rf'd bt a ghost 23:33:42 It doesn’t 23:33:46 Most rooms do not have a room address tbh 23:34:14 It _did_ have one, i added it myself 23:34:15 pov me when I tell monerica they are forced to move their channel on kyun.host matrix instance 23:34:23 It wasnt removed manually 23:35:07 Something ia wrong with the homeserver where it keeps doing a "windows system restore" or some shit 23:36:55 _all_ monero rooms are/should be addresses to matrix.org and monero.social, with monero.social as the main addr