-
br-m
<rucknium> I have Firo, Litecoin MWEB, Pirate Chain, Zano, and Zcash on my list of chains that discovered counterfeiting flaws this year. Am I missing anyone?
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> I wonder if we can consider Monero missing to the list as a good news or bad news.
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> it is a good news because there is no public counterfeiting.
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> but its a bad news in that if there is one monero is such the only serious privacy cryptocurrency people are willing to keep it secret.
-
br-m
<rucknium> I forgot Beam, too.
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> there is a crypto named Beam?
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> oh well
-
br-m
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> > This discovery underscores the enduring value of careful cryptographic review, which allowed identifying such a subtle flaw that eluded multiple professional audits as well as state-of-the-art AI agents.
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> Cypherstack has a great future ahead of them
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> Not if their human reviewers miss stuff 💀
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> they don't
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> (ignore wownero incident)
-
br-m
<rucknium> > <@syntheticbird> but its a bad news in that if there is one monero is such the only serious privacy cryptocurrency people are willing to keep it secret.
-
br-m
<rucknium> IMHO, if a Monero counterfeiting vulnerability were exploited maliciously in the wild, there would be clear public signs. Unless somehow the exploit could only produce 0.1 XMR counterfeit coins for every 1 XMR real coin, or something like that.
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> @syntheticbird: What about the Carrot spec audit
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> @jpk68:matrix.org: they missed something ?
-
br-m
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> @rucknium: Probably yes. I still categorize it as being the attacker mistake to do so
-
br-m
<rucknium> @syntheticbird: What's the Wownero incident? Has any part of wownero been audited, except code it copied from Monero?
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> @rucknium: all i remember is that last year cypherstack audited an update of Wownero and missed that bulletproof wasn't wired
-
br-m
<rucknium> An adversary would want to sell as much counterfeit XMR as quickly as possible because other actors might spot the same flaw soon. The counterfeiter might only avoid that if they can resist greed.
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> Has something like a stressnet ever been tried, but with a purposeful inflation bug, to see how it could play out?
-
br-m
<rucknium> I don't know if there would be consequences for anyone who counterfeited XMR. And how would you prove it was them?
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> @rucknium: pretty sure this a study case of game theory
-
br-m
<rucknium> @rucknium: Also violates the no bliss point (
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bliss_point_(economics)) assumption.
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> @rucknium: if it was bitcoin they would be tortured in an unknown location by a 3 letter agencies. If it's monero pretty sure the justice system wouldn't care. not gonna bet on a criminal vendetta however
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> Yeah, this is more out of pure curiosity rather than trying to prove something
-
br-m
<rucknium> @jpk68:matrix.org: Stressnet is a new and overdue concept. Only happened when there as a "practice" stressnet on mainnet by an adversary that uncovered a lot of duct tape in the node code.
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> @rucknium: interesting
-
br-m
<rucknium> @jpk68:matrix.org: Do you mean try to model economic behavior without incentivized actors? If you just have a technical testnet with a counterfeiting flaw, you would just see the testnet operators exploiting it. Not a lot of knowledge to be gained there.
-
tevador
Has anyone run a frontier LLM review of Monero with emphasis on counterfeiting bugs?
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> yes
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> multiple time
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> or at least I remember people in this channel claiming they did. I don't know if a vulnerability report came through.
-
br-m
<rucknium> AFAIK, sech1 has done it a lot.
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> @rucknium:monero.social: No, I didn't mean anything nearly that complex. I was thinking of it like watching the globs of wax floating in a lava lamp, lol
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> Just some random idea I blurted out
-
br-m
<rucknium> A way to entertain the twisted mind.
-
br-m
<rucknium> Like this?
xkcd.com/350
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> Or perhaps those games where you send an asteroid to blow up earth would be a better analogy :D
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> "Solar Smash"
-
sech1
-
sech1
But newer LLMs refuse to do it, cyber security guards trigger
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> LFM 2.5 250M Uncensored will save us all
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> Will they even refuse to re-validate a previous report, or check it for completeness?
-
br-m
<interestingband:matrix.org> (How is it going ? 3rd identity ? :D)
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> what ?
-
br-m
<interestingband:matrix.org> LOL, that's not for you
-
br-m
<a45354357456:matrix.org> sech1: jailbreak it
-
br-m
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> >based username
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> >based profile picture
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> >based message
-
br-m
<syntheticbird> you have all my respect
-
br-m
<qttps:matrix.org> sech1: Ill give it a try for ya