-
spirobel[m]
<Rucknium[m]> "anarkiocrypto: I believe..." <- just because there has been talk does not mean it will be. I also think the argument is not really convincing. people pay for transactions in kb and its their own business what they put in there. they paid for it. nebulous arguments like "transaction uniformity" dont make much sense in this case. Because transaction uniformity of the average user is not harmed by people using tx_extra
-
spirobel[m]
for other things. I think it could be used for a (domain) name system for example. Chat is impractical.
-
scip9[m]
<spirobel[m]> "just because there has been talk..." <- Any transaction that stands out hurts transaction uniformity of everyone.
-
spirobel[m]
<scip9[m]> "Any transaction that stands..." <- people using the standard monero software to make transactions are not impacted in any way shape or form by a different kind of people that use different software that uses txextra to rent domain names. or sell tokens. the monero crowd still looks exactly the same. its just that a second crowd appears next to it and they both benefit.
-
scip9[m]
<spirobel[m]> "people using the standard monero..." <- Extra functions could syphon ppl away from standard monero software.
-
scip9[m]
And I am not sure how those functions have to rely on tx extra.
-
Rucknium[m]
<spirobel[m]> "people using the standard monero..." <- I agree that just because it is being discussed doesn't mean it will actually be eliminated. However, your statement here is not really correct since all users use other transaction outputs as mixins. To the extent that certain tx uniformity defects can separate real spends from mixins, that affects the blockchain as a whole.
-
spirobel[m]
<Rucknium[m]> "I agree that just because it..." <- but the solution to this is not to remove tx_extra. There are other things malicious or not malicious actors could do to reduce transaction uniformity. so the selection of the other transaction outputs should ensure that transaction uniformity is not violated.
-
carrington[m]
Any fun ideas for using tx_extra should be in some other mergemined chain, IMO. Monero outputs/transactions should be as homogeneous as possible for it to function as fungible money
-
rbrunner
I am quite sure that as soon as somebody starts to use tx_extra in earnest for a sizable number of transactions opinion will finally sway decidedly towards eliminating it
-
rbrunner
Right now it's something like a stalemate, but use / abuse will probably sway it
-
Halver[m]
Why not simply limit the size of this `tx_extra` field ?
-
Halver[m]
`if size(tx_extra) > 1KB reject tx`
-
Chamus
<Rucknium[m]> "or would be able to understand them anyway" <- Man, why do you think you're so special because you studied statistics?
-
Chamus
For what is wirth
-
Chamus
I offer to run two targeted searches for two PhD's in statistics that are certifiable better than Rucknium just so I do not have to put up with him telling us how great he is, how dumb we are, and how much we need him
-
Chamus
If any of the people on MRL would like to help me define the ideal profile, I'll happily search until we on board two top academic researchers
-
Chamus
Just let me know
-
Chamus
<Rucknium[m]> "or would be able to understand them anyway" - Just keep in mind you're self-recruited talent, by definition the worst talent one can get
-
Chamus
S don't get too cocky, Monero is a big deal and would have no problem attracting proper top talent with the right approach
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Rucknium is fine, he donates his own time to help Monero and he isn't egoistic at all. Sure, more statisticians would be helpful, but Rucknium is a good guy and has skills.
-
Chamus
I'm offerig to bring better guys with better skills
-
Chamus
Ruck can stay under this plan, of course
-
Chamus
:p
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Bring whoever you want. More people who care about Monero's technology & use cases as private, uncensorable, financially inclusive money is always good. But you don't need to personally insult Rucknium.
-
Chamus
Where did I insult him?
-
rbrunner
"certifiable better than Rucknium". How would that even work ...
-
rbrunner
IMHO, with this "or would be able to understand them anyway" you are quoting out of context to paint them in a bad light
-
rbrunner
"or would be able to understand them anyway" Are you a recruiter, in any case?
-
rbrunner
Sorry, meant to copy this here: " I offer to run two targeted searches for two PhD's in statistics"
-
Chamus
<rbrunner> "How would that even work", amount and quality of past research, number of papers publish, number of citations, years of experience, post docs,...
-
Chamus
I am a headhunter, yes
-
rbrunner
So Rucknium is not anonymous? Did I assume that too early?
-
Chamus
He is
-
Chamus
He is passive talent though
-
Chamus
By definition we can get better than self recruited people
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
> "so I do not have to put up with him", "the worst talent", "don't get too cocky"
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
But I'm really not interested in arguments. Recruit whoever you want. More people in Monero is better for Monero, as long as they support Monero's ideals (privacy, censorship-resistance, financial inclusion).
-
Chamus
We target instead, making the talent we bring way more relevant
-
rbrunner
We can? Oh dear.
-
Chamus
Yes, we just need to define the ideal profile
-
rbrunner
I have a hunch that Chamus won't recruit anyone for working anywhere without pay ...
-
rbrunner
Ah, oh, I get it. He is also "passive talent". Because, did anyone here call for a headhunter?
-
Chamus
"1 great engineer is worth 100 average ones" / "1 great engineer is worth 100 average ones"
-
Chamus
<rbrunner> "I have a hunch that Chamus won't recruit anyone for working anywhere without pay" <- Well clearly you should not to rush, you're not that good at it
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
100 average engineers is also good and it's better to try to not be dependent on one single individual. Monero is open source, anyone can contribute, it isn't a secret corporate project for insiders only.
-
plowsof[m]
rbrunner: They can have a free wishlist 😄
-
Chamus
I have already proposed a systematic way to turn Monero into a Talent Acquisition powerhouse, while solving descentralisation Justin wants for his fund, and allowing us to legally funel funding for development globally, and offer to run all that pro bono
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Then make your own alternative to CCS and it can run in parallel.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Free market has competition and alternatives.
-
Chamus
so curious <rbrunner> what of the things I said made you think I was looking to profiteer of Monero instead of volunteer work for many 10k's of dollars?
-
Chamus
<anarkiocrypto[m]> "Then make your own alternative to CCS and it can run in parallel" - If there is one thing is not going to happen is me debating my way for the community to allow me to volunteer. I already presented my proposal. You can see that is clearly the only professional proposal. The other two drafts (Ruck's and Justin's oh-so-desired
-
Chamus
development fund that he wants to run) are amateur, unviable, unsustainable, do not solve the problems we had with Sarang and are likely to score us mediocre talent at best
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Monero is open source, you don't need to ask anyone's permission to do something.
-
Chamus
I need the support of the community to make it happen though
-
Chamus
Amateur unviable proposals are sucking in all the support of the community, and I have no beef with that really. If they actually end up working and by chance attracting top talent, awesome!
-
Chamus
Is not like I'm dying to donate 4-5 hours of work everyday to anyone
-
Halver[m]
Chamus: So, begin being much more soft and polite as now.
-
Halver[m]
As you are proceeding you'll just catch absolutely nobody.
-
Chamus
My bad, I just saw to many instances of Ruck talking down on the rest of the community that I had to speak up
-
Halver[m]
s/as/than/
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Then post your proposal to Reddit, Monero meetings, Twitter, etc. No one is censoring you. If there is demand in the community and free market, they will show it. You also don't need 100% support, even a smaller workgroup would help (easier to work with like-minded people than to try to make everyone happy).
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
I never saw Rucknium insult anyone. He just wants to help and make Monero safer via his statistics contributions.
-
Chamus
I said "talking down", not "insulting", why the need to twist the words?
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Talking down is a subset of insulting.
-
Chamus
Not to me
-
Chamus
I speak 6 languages
-
Chamus
Apologies if my english is not super precise
-
plowsof[m]
Talking down is disrespectful
-
Chamus
It is!
-
rbrunner
" I have already proposed a systematic way to turn Monero into a Talent Acquisition powerhouse" Can I read up on this anywhere already?
-
Chamus
Sure thing buddy
-
Chamus
One sec
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
4 languages here, but doesn't matter. Talking down, insulting, disrespect, etc. isn't productive and drives people away.
-
plowsof[m]
"amateur unviable proposals" , i feel attacked
-
rbrunner
If that's a counter in how many languages you can ruin a first impression, as dear Chamus right now is in danger of doing, it really does not matter.
-
Chamus
Monero has everything it takes to become a global powerhouse in top-talent attraction, and the community should rush to capitalise on this potential.
-
Chamus
The “ideal” legal structure for funnelling funding is possibly the biggest issue in the way of Monero development. Community funding should only get funnelled through non-for-profit vehicles. Period.
-
Chamus
There’s no need for any “Monero development funds” managed by a board of a handful of elected members, and there is certainly no need to funnel CCS funding through for-profit entities like we tried to in the past.
-
Chamus
I worked as a headhunter for the tech industry globally and for over a decade. I have been exposed to FLOSS and innovation management as well as with countless searches for technical profiles, and think there is a way in which which Monero could start embarking top talent sistematically
-
Chamus
The approach would look as follows:
-
Chamus
1. We interview Core Team members, MRL members and Top Monero Devs to see what are the most urgent, relevant, revolutionary research and features they could conceive Monero needs/could have if we only we had the right people working on it
-
Chamus
2. We decide talent needs on a per project basis and present CCS proposals for funding
-
Chamus
3. If proposal gets funded we go to the market and headhunt for the right talent to head the projects (I’d be happy to run these searches pro bono)
-
Chamus
4. If we're able to recruit the right talent (which we will if the budget is there) we open a “disposable” Estonian NGO (Estonia’s ease of compliance and “E-Residency” provide the ideal structure to funnel funding for such universal FLOSS Projects as Monero) that wil only serve to fund the salaries of the devs working on that one
-
Chamus
particular CCS-funded project. Once the project is completed, the Estonian NGO gets forever shutdown. So not “the Monero Foundation” but disposable “monero foundations”, as to avoid centralisation.
-
Chamus
5. If we're unable to recruit (once again, unlikely if we have the budget), money goes back to donors
-
Chamus
6. Then we move to the next projects and follow steps 1-5 once again
-
atomfried[m]
nobody wants to work for monero if the only thing you get is a lot of drama from a bitching community ...
-
atomfried[m]
it is not like monero didnt attract talent in the past, but just lost them over fuckin drama and bullshit
-
plowsof[m]
Chamus is the person who has deemed me unemployable because i dont have 10 years experience with a framework thats 3 years old ? 😁
-
Chamus
hahaha
-
Chamus
No, no
-
Chamus
I'm a thoughtful headhunter :)
-
atomfried[m]
also nobody wants to go though a fuckin 20 step procedure to just do stuff. the more Bureaucracy we add for anybody to get stuff done the less stuff will be getting done... thats my oppinion
-
plowsof[m]
headhunter is a triggering word for 'cyberpunks' , glad you're a good one!
-
Chamus
Monero has a problem, I know how to solve it, and I want to help
-
Chamus
Sorry if the way I make ends meet is disliked by you
-
atomfried[m]
i am just saying what i think, not of your solution, but overall
-
Chamus
What do you mean?
-
Chamus
Nobody wants to work for a corporation because they need to register and do paperwork first, you say?
-
atomfried[m]
Chamus: no thats not what i said, i said the more bureaucracy, the less stuff is getting done
-
Chamus
Nothing is getting done now
-
Chamus
So we can't do much less than now, really
-
Chamus
In terms of talent acquisition
-
atomfried[m]
Chamus: seraphis, p2p protocol rework, the decoy selection is reengineered, a hf is prepared with a larger ringsize + BP+, what are you talking about
-
atomfried[m]
less stuff is getting done than some times ago, but imo thats because of the increase in drama in the community
-
atomfried[m]
atomfried[m]: thats just my feeling
-
rbrunner
They are right insofar as no systematic talent acquisition is currently running, to my knowledge
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
I don't see why you can't run your Estonian company route in parallel to CCS, Justin's idea, Plowsof's wishlists, etc.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
CCS is still necessary because it's KYC-free and has direct Monero payments (personally I'm not interested in taking anyone's money and if I would contribute to Monero it would be for free, but I am a full-stack web developer with 10 years experience, and wouldn't be able use your Estonian company route due to no ID or bank account).
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
For non-pseudonymous devs who can pass KYC and want invoices, bank transfers, employment contracts, etc. your Estonian company route could be useful as an available alternative.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
IDK how much it costs for you. Maybe make a website with the details and potential Monero devs can contact you and arrange this Estonian company route on a per-project basis for a fee?
-
Chamus
<atomfried[m]> "Chamus: seraphis, p2p protocol rework, the decoy selection is reengineered, a hf is prepared with a larger ringsize + BP+, what are you talking about" <- In terms of Talent Acquisition, I meant
-
Chamus
You can read it above
-
atomfried[m]
Chamus: ahhh ok i see
-
Chamus
<atomfried[m]> "seraphis, p2p protocol rework, the decoy selection is reengineered, a hf is prepared with a larger ringsize + BP+, what are you talking about" <- If all those things are happening without any systematyc approach to Talent Acquisition in Monero, think were would be if we only had more great people working on it! ;)
-
Halver[m]
Chamus: This is 1/ insulting 2/ shows clearly you don't follow closely all which is done (and wdoesn't help qualify you here)
-
Halver[m]
s/wdoesn/doesn/
-
rbrunner
"Estonian company route in parallel to CCS, Justin's idea, Plowsof's wishlists, etc" Yeah, I don't see how you can rally most of the community behind a single thing
-
atomfried[m]
Chamus: we had a lot of great people working on things and lost them, the question is why they are gone and i think we should fix that
-
rbrunner
It's just too wild a bunch, that community
-
Chamus
Justin is centralised, he has absolute veto power and Magic only works with American Talent
-
Chamus
While my approach is descentralised and global
-
Chamus
Those are the main differences
-
Chamus
Having a dictator calling shots or not having one
-
Chamus
Do you really not like mine better?
-
atomfried[m]
Chamus: depends on how efficient it is
-
Chamus
Both proposals are on paper only
-
Chamus
Which one has more merit, you reckon? ;)
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Both can run in parallel. Anything that requires KYC, company registration, banking, etc. is irrelevant to me personally but I understand how it can help people who want a traditional employment/salary structure.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Devs could choose to use Justin's US company, your EU company, CCS, Plowsof's wishlists, or their own funding models.
-
Chamus
Defo man, the more people recruiting for Monero the absolute better!
-
Chamus
Yes, agree
-
atomfried[m]
allowing all kinds of funding models is also pretty decentralized :D
-
Chamus
Yes sir
-
Chamus
I agree
-
atomfried[m]
let the researchers and devs decide which funding model they want to choose 🚀
-
Chamus
The thing is
-
Chamus
Once again
-
Chamus
Only American researchers would get to choose
-
Chamus
Global talent would need to be funded through the Estonian NGO
-
Chamus
Magic can't do that
-
rbrunner
I am a little confused now, unfortunately. What is holding you up right now, Chamus? I mean, some worthwhile goal should not be too hard to find, and then go headhunting?
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
If your EU companies are disposable, surely you only need to register it after you have found a dev for a project and discussed this model with them. You can start your idea now without "the community's backing", maybe make a Github Pages website for it, and market this as an alternative to CCS Monero payments for people who want a traditional employment structure. You don't need anyone's permission. Just advertise this option
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
and individual devs can choose to work with you if they prefer this model.
-
Chamus
The thick of the support went for Ruck's proposal, so I said I'd be stepping aside and offer again if alternative approaches did not work
-
rbrunner
What is "Ruck's proposal"?
-
Chamus
An approach that relies on the self-recruitment of anons who want to get paid in Monero
-
Chamus
he wants to scale his very personal circumstances to a systematic recruitment approach
-
rbrunner
Well, we do that basically since 2014, why this should now suddenly be "Ruck's proposal" and even hold you up?
-
Chamus
The approach ignores many market realities, though
-
Chamus
Many
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
"Anons who want to get paid in Monero" is completely fine and in the spirit of Monero, cypherpunk and cryptocurrency. Meritocratic, accessible and not gatekept by state regulations such as KYC or company registration.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
You can offer your disposable Estonian companies today. Make a website for it, add a contact form, and you can work with individual devs on a per-project basis.
-
Chamus
<anarkiocrypto[m]> "is completely fine and in the spirit of Monero, cypherpunk and cryptocurrency" <- Is that scalable though?
-
Chamus
Those are the market realities that are being ignored
-
rbrunner
I am still quite confused who you argue with here, and who you would like to convince to do what.
-
Chamus
I'm not arguing with anyone?
-
rbrunner
Replace that with "discussing".
-
rbrunner
And "to do what" is anyway the core of my question :)
-
Chamus
I'm answering all of y'alls questions on my proposal, that is it
-
Chamus
I'm answering
-
Chamus
Not arguing or discussing
-
Chamus
To do what?
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Bitcoin has millions of users worldwide, software, wallets, platforms, markets, use cases, etc. and its founder was pseudonymous. Monero likewise has thousands of users and many pseudonymous devs and it works absolutely fine. There are also risks for KYC'ed devs. Even the "Western world" such as EU and USA is hostile toward Monero & working on private permissionless peer-to-peer cash could put a target on your back. If that's
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
a decision you want to take, go ahead. If not, go for pseudonymous dev, as it has been working for Bitcoin since 2009.
-
Chamus
For now, I'm gonna hold my proposal and re offer if alternative approaches do not work
-
Chamus
As I said
-
Chamus
What I do offer now
-
rbrunner
Ok. Answering questions sounds good. Why don't you go ahead with your proposal. what is holding you up?
-
Chamus
Is to run two searches for academic researches
-
Chamus
If there is need and someone wants to step in and define the ideal profile
-
Chamus
<rbrunner> - I do not think the proposal was popular enough to make it
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Launch it and people will contact you if there is demand.
-
Chamus
So I will hold and re-offer if alternative approaches do not work
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
If the companies are created on a per-project basis, costs should only materialize after you have found devs (and devs could pay a fee for the convenience of your company setup).
-
Chamus
All that is up to discuss, I have no agenda really
-
Chamus
But yes, see point 5 of my proposal
-
rbrunner
"popular enough to make it" If we bring that down to Earth, do you think a corresponding CCS would not get funded?
-
Chamus
Not without the support of figureheads
-
Chamus
Go try and explain why an Estonian NGO is an ideal vehicle for this
-
Chamus
See what kind of resistance you encounter :P
-
rbrunner
Well, point 1. (coming up with a worthwhile project) and point 2. (setting up a CCS) do not seem overly hard for me, would not cost much to just try, seems to me.
-
rbrunner
I have seen many surprises already with the Monero community
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
That's the free market showing its demand. But there's no reason to not make a simple Github Pages website and offer your "CCS -> Estonian company" proxy service on-demand to devs who would otherwise want to work on Monero but would prefer a formal employment structure. It would be on a case-by-case basis with customized services per dev, not a universal solution for all devs.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
No need for figureheads. Monero is an open source project. No CEOs, no leaders, no one to ask for permission.
-
Chamus
Is not an Estonian Company man!
-
Chamus
Very important point!
-
Chamus
Is a non-for-profit organisation in Estonia
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Estonian disposable NGO then
-
rbrunner
Even better then?!?
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
It's your project, advertise it how you wish.
-
rbrunner
No, really there will *always* somebody who complains, whatever you do.
-
Chamus
I know
-
Chamus
To be honest
-
Chamus
That is also why I am afraid to push it
-
Chamus
I really do not have the will to debate my way so the community allows me to volunteer
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
There is no "allowing" or "permission". Make a website, make a contact form, offer these services on-demand and people will take your offer if they are interested.
-
Chamus
These are not on deman services man
-
Chamus
This is a systematic, scalable and sustainable approach to Talent Acquisiton for Moneroç
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
It is a disposable NGO per dev/per project.
-
Chamus
Per project!
-
Chamus
As a project might need an academic researcher and two devs maybe
-
Chamus
I do not define that
-
Chamus
Core and Top Devs would
-
rbrunner
Now I oppose the use of a word: "debate". No need for debate. It's quite easy-going: The CCS will get funded, or it won't. See, wasn't hard? Nothing to be afraid of.
-
Chamus
Haha
-
Chamus
You good man ;)
-
rbrunner
Really not sure how you mean that, but the core of my argument is dead serious.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Yes, so it's unique per project, therefore on-demand. There is not a catch-all permanent organization like Justin's idea. So you can advertise this model now, and if a project is interested in using it, they will take your offer and you can register the disposable NGO.
-
Chamus
Ah ok
-
Chamus
Sorry, I thought you meant this would be a fixture offered to potential talent coming "on demand"
-
Chamus
My bad english again :p
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
No worries, I'm not a native speaker either. On-demand = you offer a custom solution per project after discussion with devs.
-
Chamus
<rbrunner> "Really not sure how you mean that, but the core of my argument is dead serious" <- You're good as in "your a good peep for motivating me to do this"
-
rbrunner
Ok :)
-
Chamus
Haha
-
Chamus
let me think about it, I would have to spend 20 hours on it weekly at least
-
Chamus
I'm ready to do that
-
Chamus
But since I'm ready to do that I really do not wish to have to debate my way, makes sense no?
-
Chamus
I was working on this plan with Geonic
-
Chamus
he offered to help me make this happening
-
Chamus
Let me talk to him
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Charge the devs a convenience fee for the NGO registration/employment contract/salary via bank transfer, etc.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Just write your idea. If the free market is interested, they will take your offer. If not, it's neither your fault nor their fault, just how the market is right now.
-
Chamus
In the meantime, the offer for the two academic researchers is open if anyone is willing to define a blessed profile
-
Chamus
<anarkiocrypto[m]> "it's neither your fault nor their fault, just how the market is right now" <- 100% agree man
-
Chamus
I have zero emotional investment in this proposal
-
Chamus
I just love Monero and think I could help it, so I offered
-
Chamus
:)
-
Chamus
Will talk to geonic and get you back on this but if any of core, or MRL want to take me on my academic researcher search offer, just hit me up! :)
-
Chamus
Now I'm off to enjoy my sunday
-
Chamus
Have a blessed one y'all
-
atomfried[m]
Chamus: enjoy 🙌
-
carrington[m]
Chamus the first step of your plan is to interview devs and researchers to develop a talent profile. I would suggest just going ahead and doing that without asking permission. Most devs and researchers can be reached by a variety of platforms so you can contact them
-
Save_G[m]
Hello good day
-
Save_G[m]
I'm looking for something that explains business owners on how to implement xmr to be accepted in their business with btc payserver for example or other ways for automating processes
-
Save_G[m]
it should also include principles, economics, etc.. of Monero and how accepting btc puts the business and customers at risk because of the transparency.
-
Save_G[m]
is there something like that in a website, document or copypasta form?
-
carrington[m]
Save_G there is
-
carrington[m]
-
carrington[m]
But that doesn't have the second part of your requirements
-
Save_G[m]
ok thank you very much
-
Save_G[m]
I could send this combined with the /xmrgen/ infodump to people but it's currently down for maintenance
-
ajs_[m]
Chamus: Please be aware that non-profit companies are highly regulated enities and usally have strict accounting requirements. They are not as easy to manage as an LLC.
-
ajs_[m]
Having a LLC doesn't necessarily mean you must operate the entity for a profit, it can have an altruistic aim.
-
Chamus
<carrington[m]> "I would suggest just going ahead and doing that without asking permission. Most devs and researchers can be reached by a variety of platforms so you can contact them" <- I tried in the past. Contacted two top Monero devs for this, but was ignored. I know I should keep trying but, it takes a lot of motivation to go out of your way
-
Chamus
to get people to allow you to volunteer
-
Chamus
ajs_[m]> "Please be aware that non-profit companies are highly regulated enities" <- Are "highly regulated entities" in what jurisdictions you mean?
-
Chamus
There's no where easier in the world to run both a company or a non-for-profit than in Estonia
-
Chamus
Having said that community funding should only be funnelled to non-for-profit vehicles
-
Chamus
Even more when it is super easy and straightforward to do it
-
Chamus
Also this disposable organisations would be as straightforward as they come in terms of the already easy to comply-with legislation in Estonia
-
Chamus
Once again, I have no emotional investment on this approach, I just doubt we will find a more effective one
-
ajs_[m]
In most jurisdictions, non-profits are regulated more than LLCs. Just wanted to give you a heads up what potentially you are getting yourself into. Consultant with a Estonian lawyer and accountant to make sure you are "playing by the rules"
-
Chamus
Yes sir
-
Chamus
This is something I have thought for long
-
Chamus
And have experience starting organisations in several legislations
-
Chamus
That's why I suggest Estonia
-
Chamus
But you're right
-
Chamus
in the US, and most elsewhere, it is a completely different ball game in terms of complexity
-
Chamus
:)
-
plowsof[m]
i did not require permission to create a wishlist, and begin a new funding experiment, lets see how it goes
plowsof.github.io
-
plowsof[m]
We all should have them 👆️😁
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
> actually i dont know what they think as nobody replies to my applications
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Sorry to hear this. :( Hope you can find some work for Monero and your wishlist will be successful. Maybe t.me/MoneroJobs, Microlancer.io, FreelanceForCoins.com can help. I learned programming over 10 years ago so IDK what are good guides nowadays but let me know if you need any technical help.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
One suggestion is a bounty website (reverse CCS) where people can suggest use cases and fundraise them, then devs can work on them. E.g. someone wants a Monero Etsy clone, makes a bounty and people donate to it. Then a dev sees that x people are interested in this idea and a x XMR payment is available. The dev develops the Etsy clone, uploads the source to Github and receives the Monero bounty.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Sometimes it can be difficult as a dev to know what ideas would have market demand, have active users, or be profitable. Bounties show 1) what people want and 2) a way to fund development (so you don't work for free until it possibly becomes profitable or even used).
-
Chamus
That is a crazy good idea man
-
Chamus
Honestly
-
Chamus
<anarkiocrypto[m]> "Sometimes it can be difficult as a dev to know what ideas would have market demand, have active users, or be profitable" <- Agree 100%
-
plowsof[m]
Someone bought me a coffee 😭
-
Chamus
<plowsof[m]> "New funding experiment" <- This is cool man!
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Maybe Plowsof's wishlist script and a Github page could be used for this bounty website idea and wanted use cases could be suggested via Github. Someone would need to custody the bounties until a dev has completed the work and released the source (I don't want to manage any funds personally).
-
Chamus
Me neither if my proposal ever went through
-
Chamus
But you guys might be unto something here!
-
sethsimmons
> <@anarkiocrypto:halogen.city>
-
sethsimmons
> Maybe Plowsof's wishlist script and a Github page could be used for this bounty website idea and wanted use cases could be suggested via Github. Someone would need to custody the bounties until a dev has completed the work and released the source (I don't want to manage any funds personally).
-
sethsimmons
A few of us are building a focused bounty/idea site and its close to being done, FWIW
-
sethsimmons
Just finalizing a few details
-
Chamus
That would be a crazy good source for development ideas
-
sethsimmons
For proposing and helping to fund ideas around the Monero ecosystem outside of full CCS requests.
-
Chamus
Glad y'all thought of it and are working on it!
-
sethsimmons
But more details are coming
-
Chamus
Cheers
-
plowsof[m]
The hive mind at work
-
sethsimmons
Yup, been in the works a while but all of us have had things come up that has delayed a bit.
-
sethsimmons
The actual site itself and tool are up and working, just defining scope and fund handling procedures is the trickier part.
-
sethsimmons
I'm going to try and get it pushed through this week if I can get everyone together, its much needed.
-
anarkiocrypto[m]
Good to hear Seth :)
-
Halver[m]
-
plowsof[m]
ping monero observer?😁
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
<sethsimmons> "> <@sethsimmons:monero.social> A..." <- Sounds very interesting. You can ping me when it's ready and I will post a report on Monero Observer. Seth
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
> <@anarkiocrypto:halogen.city> "Anons who want to get paid in Monero" is completely fine and in the spirit of Monero, cypherpunk and cryptocurrency. Meritocratic, accessible and not gatekept by state regulations such as KYC or company registration.
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
>
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
> You can offer your disposable Estonian companies today. Make a website for it, add a contact form, and you can work with individual devs on a per-project basis.
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
I can't agree more, so I won't. Love you anarkiocrypto
-
atomfried[m]
whats your oppinion on this redesign?
-
atomfried[m]
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
atomfried: well, I published a short report on that a few hours ago on Monero Observer.
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
s/atomfried: well, I published a short report on that a few hours ago on Monero Observer./atomfried: well, I published a short report on that a few hours ago on Monero Observer (
monero.observer/getmonero-site-dark-theme-redesign-concept/).
-
escapethe3ra[m]1
Personally, otr I don't see any big issues with the current design.
-
atomfried[m]
i quite like the new redesign because it looks exactly like the wallet darkmode
-
Rucknium[m]
<Rucknium[m]> "Ok great. I have a little..." <- Chamus
-
Rucknium[m]
<Rucknium[m]> "I may be overthinking it because..." <- Chamus
-
Rucknium[m]
<Rucknium[m]> "Basically, I don't know how..." <- Chamus
-
Rucknium[m]
Chamus ^ That is the full context of the quote that you took out of context. Now on to your other points:
-
Rucknium[m]
<Chamus> "development fund that he wants..." <- Without anything more that the original post I made on Reddit happening, the following people have joined Matrix and offered to help:
-
Rucknium[m]
(I'll break up their usernames with spaces so it doesn't ping them)
-
Rucknium[m]
aharon ov_bohm ("physics graduate \[student\] (theoretical particle physics) with minors in computer science looking to contribute to monero")
-
Rucknium[m]
d3n eon ("currently working on analysing a CoinJoin protocol of another cryptocurrency")
-
Rucknium[m]
Duc kLuck ("At the moment no specific area of expertise, I am a computer engineering student...really love everything but don't know anything specifically.")
-
Rucknium[m]
bost on101 ("My background is in data engineering/modeling and I work at a sports betting company (I dont watch sports so dont ask haha). Mainly experienced with Python, sql, and math.")
-
Rucknium[m]
Cae sar ("data science undergrad...Programming languages: R,RStudio,Python,Tableau. Stat skills: Networking, Web scraping, APIs, basic analysis(linear, log multiple), possion regression, Prob theory, ML methods, optimization, Unsupervised learning techniques, big data storage computation and analysis, and to top it off alittle cli work with a supercomputer ")
-
Rucknium[m]
ellp epe ("I'm decent in C# and Java, python and javascript")
-
Rucknium[m]
mvsk okeboy ("I recently graduated with a degree in physics with an emphasis in astrophysics, and I have some coding experience")
-
Rucknium[m]
saks hamio ("I'm applying to grad school....I'm currently a data scientist working in Pharma, Open to working on review papers")
-
Rucknium[m]
ta nvir ("Hi, monero noob here but i can math and i wanna help")
-
Rucknium[m]
vall drac ("Hi, molly.im lead developer here.I've a proposal for the Monero community...We're looking to develop and deploy our own backend and build a better Signal: anonymous identities (no more phone numbers), decentralized, and resistant to traffic analysis") Unclear if they saw my Reddit post, but they joined around the same time that others who answered the post did.
-
Rucknium[m]
comp ilomatic ("CompSci undergrad from Switzerland here...I have advanced experience (descending order) in Java, C#, Rust (new favorite), Java(/Type)Script, and some experience in C, C++ and Ruby.")
-
Rucknium[m]
mone ro-marc ("I just joined the crypto space about 3 months ago. I just started my junior year in college, and my major is Computer Science. I am fairly new to the crypto space and Monero is by far my favorite project (it is easily the most undervalued crypto in my opinion).... It is my dream to become a full-time monero developer once I graduate in 2 years, but I want to contribute part-time right now with any free-time that I
-
Rucknium[m]
have.")
-
Rucknium[m]
^ That is 12 people right there and nothing in the sketch of the plan has been done. Of course, matching people to specific tasks and then getting a time commitment is another hurdle to overcome, but I think we can get there
-
Rucknium[m]
Chamus: If you do want to recruit two people with Ph.D.s in statistics, I have a profile for you:
-
Rucknium[m]
First, look for people who do applied statistics rather than theoretical statistics.
-
Rucknium[m]
Then look for people that can do one or more of the following three things:
-
Rucknium[m]
1) Someone who can analyze what is suggested in Section 6.1 of this paper and develop improvements to it. I am doing exactly that, but it would be good to have someone else develop something independently and/or review what I have developed :
sciendo.com/article/10.1515/popets-2018-0025
-
Rucknium[m]
2) In the same paper, someone who can analyze the suggestion in Section 6.2 for its resistance to statistical attack, how it might be implemented, and further pros and cons.
-
atomfried[m]
i cant seem to find the monero-recruitment room here in matrix, can anybody link it?
-
Rucknium[m]
3) Someone who can analyze the viability of the "partitioning" approach outlined here. Same thing: resistance to statistical attack, implementability, further pros and cons:
sciendo.com/article/10.2478/popets-2021-0047
-
Rucknium[m]
atomfried: #monero-recruitment:monero.social
-
Rucknium[m]
Chamus: I am really starting to doubt my initial assumption that you are acting in good faith.
-
Chamus
Rucknium[m]> "is another hurdle to overcome" <- Yes sir, before that hurdle it is all meaningless though
-
Chamus
<Rucknium[m]> I am really starting to doubt my initial assumption that you are acting in good faith <- Makes no difference to me, really
-
Chamus
<Rucknium[m]> "Then look for people that can do one or more of the following three things" <- This is extremely useful though, thanks
-
Chamus
Will review and follow up with questions when they pop up