-
n1oc
-
br-m
<kryptomatiks:matrix.org> Looks like they're working on it:
trezor/trezor-suite #29235 > <@jpk68:matrix.org> A few others (and myself) have tried to contact Trezor numerous times, to not much avail. It doesn't seem like they're too willing to have someone work on THP support in the Monero codebase themselves.
-
br-m
<kryptomatiks:matrix.org> Full monero support on Trezor Suite; not a C++ library for the THP integration but better than nothing I guess
-
br-m
<tobtoht> @kryptomatiks:matrix.org: 10k line diff co-authored by claude....
-
br-m
<tobtoht> submitted by a contributor who has 2420 merged PRs on that repo
-
br-m
<thomasbuilds:matrix.org> trezor has gone the AI route 100%
-
br-m
<thomasbuilds:matrix.org> it's not just this PR all PRs are AI
-
br-m
<entropyhoover:matrix.org> Doesn't sounds great for a security oriented product?
-
br-m
<tobtoht> what's the point of asking Trezor to do anything if they are just going to slop it?
-
plowsof
lol
-
plowsof
i think seeing them busy getting doom running on one of their devices said enough
-
br-m
<thomasbuilds:matrix.org> the PR has 8 pending reviewers some of whom are employed
-
br-m
<thomasbuilds:matrix.org> we don't know if they just ask AI to review it or do it properly
-
br-m
<thomasbuilds:matrix.org> you just need 1 reviewer to use AI properly - that's it
-
br-m
<thomasbuilds:matrix.org> all other 7 should be human reviews
-
sech1
-
plowsof
🥳
-
br-m
<rbrunner7> @kryptomatiks:matrix.org: I am not sure that for us who want to support Trezor in our wallets, this PR is "better than nothing". Worst case they will take it as an excuse: "See, Trezor support in Monero wallets is not necessary anymore, just use our Trezor Suite, problem solved".
-
br-m
<hbs:matrix.org> @rbrunner7: Never, ever, ever touch Trezor Suite (or Ledger Wallet) for anything related to assets
-
br-m
<hbs:matrix.org> @hbs:matrix.org: update firmware via trezorctl, use zknox blue to install Ledger apps
-
br-m
-
br-m
<mrcyjanek0:matrix.org> it’s definitely less than 10k lines to get the new trezor support
-
br-m
<mrcyjanek0:matrix.org> there’s also some extra code I didn’t put in the cpp code yet - and it’s done on the dart side in cake but it’s a starting point that already works
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> It may be possible to eventually take Bitcoin Core's route of splitting wallet functionality into a separate repo, where we just use the vendors' Python libraries.
-
br-m
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> @jpk68:matrix.org: Too bad they cant wplit wallet functionaity from the node
-
br-m
<jpk68:matrix.org> Not quite sure what you mean
-
br-m
<tobtoht> I don't think we should allow third party hardware integrations in the main repo. We can set up a generic USB interface, and if a vendor wants to offer Monero support they can go ahead and implement that. We have given Trezor/Ledger way too much leverage over our code and dependencies.
-
br-m
<tobtoht> Oh, we added Protobuf, guess you'll need protobuf. Oh, protobuf now depends on abseil, guess you'll need abseil. Oh, we overengineered our host protocol (thanks claude!), guess you'll go have to implement that now.
-
br-m
<mrcyjanek0:matrix.org> ^ fully support tobtoht on that one, we tried a few integrations of the new protocol and keeping the minimal scope ensures that monero is portable and anyone can use it the way they want and we also get less LOC to maintain.
-
br-m
<mrcyjanek0:matrix.org> Konsti and I from tried multiple ways of integrating trezor (and still have ledger integrated by just registering a dummy USB device…), and it’s definitely more portable and maintainable when we just get the data we need and we can just pass it to the hardware wallet using whatever is available on the OS we target.
-
br-m
<4rkal> Anyone know who's behind duskswap.com? Looks pretty cool and it's using cyphergoat ; )
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> basicswap mentioned " Currently sourcing BasicSwap and CypherGoat live; more venues are on the way."
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> also they are wrong in some circumstancec "Instant exchanges — faster, but NOT trustless" << some instant swaps still take like 50 confs iirc
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> basicswap takes the obligatory 10 to unlock the xmr. if buying ltc etc, it is usually released after 3 xmr confs
-
nioc
one swapper lists confs as 6-50 lol
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> one held my funds for 100 one time
-
br-m
<4rkal> Some exchanges may require more confirmations for large trades (eg. 50k+), but most are super fast. What is not mentioned at all on the website is the risk of receiving tainted coins, which iirc is a real issue on platforms like bisq
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> "BTC/XMR basicswap 168.941 168.755 +0.11%" basicswap al beating centralized swappers
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> "XMR/BTC 0.00591949 0.00588082 0.00592595 +0.65%" < centralized
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> @4rkal: i cant receive tainted xmr 🧠
-
br-m
<4rkal> yeah obviously
-
nioc
they are all tainted :D
-
br-m
<4rkal> We (cyphergoat) were thinking of providing liquidity on basicswap, but the primary blocker is we couldn't actually market make properly as we would only be playing the xmr receiving route. Receiving any transparent coins on a p2p marketplace comes with tainted coins risks
-
br-m
<4rkal> I think a lot more market makers would join the game if there was some way of minimizing that risk
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> you can TECHNICALLY fuck off on the swap and let it go into refund if it fails your aml
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> but id prefer you just act as an xmr buyer
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> but, as the btc side, i can play dirty too, and fuck off on the refund and force it into the swipe/mercy (which makes the trade complete
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> so id just recommend not buying transparent coins if you dont want to risk taint
-
nioc
so only buy wow
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> right. if you only buy wow, people wont pay you with tainted coins
-
br-m
<321bob321> Or buy
-
br-m
<4rkal> If anyone’s wondering why it’s been so quiet on the CypherGoat front lately, we’ve been building something new. More soon
-
br-m
<4rkal> oh and it’s invite only ; )
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr:xmr.mx> what abt twim
-
br-m
<nike_ty6:matrix.org> Hello, could someone send the latest Monero reports(website)?
-
br-m
<ofrnxmr> What is that
-
br-m
<321bob321> beta site?
-
br-m
<slowbeardigger:matrix.org> maybe
monero.observer/?
-
br-m
<nike_ty6:matrix.org> @slowbeardigger:matrix.org: Thanks
-
br-m
<321bob321> loll