-
Guest15
hello, is it posible to buy monero with eth?
-
Mochi101
Guest15, yes... at an exchange
-
garth
Woooo v0.18.1 is tagged babyyyyy
-
riceandbeans
Would RAM have any meaningful effect on mining ability?
-
hyc
you need 2.5GB. beyond that, no effect
-
riceandbeans
I randomly had this thought of doing uber/lyft, with an armada of raspberry pi's in the trunk hooked up to a 12 -> 120 converter
-
riceandbeans
Like, get them in cases and stack them maybe 10 tall and maybe 10 wide and maybe 5 deep.
-
riceandbeans
Just have them running while driving around, so the electricity isn't really a thing.
-
Mochi101
uhhh... need the gasoline to produce the electricity in the car
-
riceandbeans
I mean, yeah but assuming that's part of just uber/lyft while driving around as a taxi type thing
-
Mochi101
adding those would make the fuel consumption go up
-
riceandbeans
Doesn't make it practical, was just a random thought.
-
riceandbeans
I don't do any ride sharing stuff as it is right now, it was just...a random thought about what if I did...
-
riceandbeans
lol, assuming 10x10x5, at a cost of $35+10% sales tax per pi, at a consistent hash rate of 100H/s, producing $0.20 worth of XMR/day, it would take over 263 years to hit break even at current XMR price
-
riceandbeans
That was a fun thought experiment...
-
binaryFate
v0.18.1.0 binaries are now available at getmonero.org
-
selsta
Ledger app v1.8.0 will be released tomorrow, to download it it's necessary to enable developer mode inside Ledger Live.
-
selsta
Without developer mode the app will likely get released next week.
-
selsta
Trezor users will have to wait a couple days until the new firmware is released.
-
revuoxmr
Revuo Monero. Issue 132: August 4 - 11, 2022.
revuo-xmr.com/issue-132.html
-
Evolver
How many transactions per second can the Monero network support at most?
-
selsta
I doubt there is a number for it
-
Evolver
well, what is its known lower bound? Imagine I said "at least"
-
Evolver
e.g. the Monero network is known to be capable of supporting at least xx transfer per second.
-
Evolver
In that, what is the most that xx is known to be?
-
Evolver
It is an important question IMHO.
-
selsta
most projects who advertise with TPS are deceiving
-
selsta
e.g. they test ideal scenarios on testnet
-
selsta
real life networks have way more nodes with different hardware capabilities and also different network speeds
-
selsta
it's possible that raspberry pi nodes on slow internet connections can't keep up anymore
-
Evolver
not an answer to the question
-
selsta
0
-
selsta
is a lower bound
-
Evolver
For example, I have head that Bitcoin can support 7 tx/sec
-
Evolver
selsta: you're a troll, and so please avoid responding to me again
-
Evolver
I will restate the question for someone who isn't
-
nioc
lol
-
nioc
sounds like a question for articmine
-
selsta
Evolver: wow sorry for giving you a realistic answer
-
Evolver
hush
-
selsta
maybe you should get into Solana, I heard they support a lot of TPS
-
Evolver
go away troll
-
Evolver
This is #monero
-
Evolver
How many tx/sec is the Monero network known to comfortably support? For example, this is 7 for Bitcoin's layer 1.
-
nioc
AIUI 7 is an upper bound that realistically never gets hit
-
nioc
<selsta> most projects who advertise with TPS are deceiving
-
sech1
Evolver Monero supports 0.5 tx/sec for sure
-
sech1
-
nioc
this was discussed in MRL months ago but I have no recollection of anything
-
nioc
just guesswork
-
sech1
my notebook can sync about 1.4 blocks/second, so I guess it can handle ~80 times more transactions than it is right now
-
sech1
so about 40 tx/sec?
-
Mochi101
-
selsta
monero has a dynamic block size which means it does not have a fixed limit
-
Mochi101
Average tx value is also pretty sweet...
-
nioc
Mochi101: lololol
-
selsta
but people with slow network and bad hardware won't be able to keep up at some point
-
Mochi101
Sent coins in USD... blew me away.
-
Evolver
Would adding more nodes to the Monero network allow it to support more tps (if this were a limiting factor)?
-
selsta
Evolver: it's the opposite
-
Evolver
what then if someone purposefully adds a thousand slow nodes?
-
Evolver
Wouldn't that compromise the network?
-
Evolver
What is the safeguard against that?
-
selsta
then they won't be able to keep up with the nerwork
-
sech1
Slow nodes is a problem for their owners, not for the network
-
Evolver
selsta: so how is it the opposite
-
selsta
because the higher you go with TPS the less nodes will be able to keep up
-
sech1
^
-
sech1
my notebook can handle 40 tx/sec
-
sech1
some EPYC server will probably be able to handle more than 1000 tx/sec
-
Evolver
The motivation for me asking is that if Monero's adoption grows, wouldn't this become a limiting factor at some point...
-
Evolver
or maybe Epyc would become a bare minimum requirement then
-
Evolver
or what am I not understanding
-
selsta
well hopefully as monero adoption grows hardware capabilities also improve
-
Evolver
so do the slower nodes then get auto-kicked out
-
selsta
and cryptography also gets better
-
selsta
you can run a node on a raspberry currently so there is still a lot of room
-
selsta
slower nodes don't necessarily get kicked, they just can't keep up with the network and are behind
-
Evolver
Do they slow down the network then?
-
Evolver
I mean imagine there are 1000 Epyc nodes and 100 RPi nodes.
-
Evolver
Will the latter slow down the network?
-
Rucknium[m]
Evolver: Define "slow down the network". If you cannot define this precisely, then you need to DYOR and then come back.
-
Evolver
Rucknium[m]: Agreed. I mean two things. Due to presence of those 100 RPi nodes: (1) Will transactions take much longer to confirm (if the request load is variable)? (2) Will transactions fail altogether to confirm (if the request load is persistently high enough for those RPis but not for Epycs)?
-
Evolver
Assume that if the RPis were absent, there would be no issues.
-
Rucknium[m]
selsta, correct me if I'm wrong, but the Monero node daemon is now fairly aggressive in disconnecting (banning) other nodes if their performance is very poor, since the December 2020(?) network troubles, right?
-
Evolver
Another way to ask the question is: in the face of persistently high tps, would the addition of slow nodes be considered an attack?
-
selsta
I'm not sure how it works in detail currently, but either way the RPi should not make a difference.
-
sech1
slow nodes will not slow down the whole network
-
Rucknium[m]
Relaying blocks and relaying transactions are two different tasks.
-
sech1
otherwise we'd get this attack by now already
-
sech1
kind of an obvious attack vector
-
Rucknium[m]
For BTC, initial syncing from the genesis block may be slowing down, possibly due to more RPis on the network. See:
blog.lopp.net/is-bitcoin-network-slowing-down
-
Evolver
sech1: I mean an attack vector especially when the network is already running at capacity, not now
-
Rucknium[m]
I have had to sync a few BTC and BCH nodes from genesis block recently and the BCH network has been consistently faster in syncing, at about 50% faster, measured up until the Aug 2017 hard fork block.
-
sech1
every node has its own capacity
-
sech1
there's no single number for the whole network
-
Rucknium[m]
In general proof-of-work blockchains like bitcoin and Monero are meant to be resistant to Sybil attacks on the network level. Slow nodes would be a type of Sybil attack.
-
Rucknium[m]
-
hyc
if a single node had its peer list filled with slow nodes then it would also get slowed down
-
hyc
all the charts I've seen of BTC have never exceeded 3.5 tx/sec
-
Evolver
ok
-
hyc
as for BTC vs BCH, presumably their pre-hardfork content and crypto code is identical. strange that they'd have any perf differences
-
Evolver
Has the Monero software and network seen any major non-maintenance improvements over say the last five years? I'm asking as a noob. Or is it frozen in time? What have been a few major new features over the years?
-
hyc
anyway, I suspect raspberry Pis will continue to be useful for a few more years. there's a difference though between being able to sustain daily traffic, vs
-
hyc
catching up from behind after a long period offline, or doing an initial block download
-
hyc
most Pis now would take months to sync up from scratch
-
hyc
many improvements over the years. None that can be explained simply.
-
Evolver
-
hyc
adopting LMDB ws in itself a huge performance boost
twitter.com/hyc_symas/status/717076693446475777
-
hyc
while Monero txns are ~4-5x larger than BTC txns, Monero infrastructure is multiple orders of magnitude faster than BTC software
-
hyc
-
hyc
-
Evolver
ah
-
hyc
the questions you're asking are kinda boring, ancient history here
-
Evolver
Are you fucking kiddine me
-
Evolver
The tx rate of a cryptocurrency is a most basic question, and the answer here was not obvious at all
-
Evolver
Looking at that big release log, it is not at all evident what was a big feature.
-
Evolver
You're always welcome to just stfu and not feel obliged to reply.
-
Evolver
If I am going to use and promote Monero, I am most definitely going to ask all kinds of questions.
-
Evolver
I am doing you the courtesy of not asking in the dev channel.
-
Mochi101
Evolver, get a grip.